Heretic, a psychological thriller directed by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, presents an intriguing yet somewhat predictable tale of two young missionaries, Sister Paxton (Chloe East) and Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher), who are on a seemingly routine mission. But what starts as a simple visit quickly morphs into a battle of faith, manipulation, and moral conflict, when they meet the enigmatic Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant).

Plot Overview

The film begins on a cold, rainy day, with Sister Paxton and Sister Barnes making their rounds to convince potential converts to the Church of Mormon. Their journey takes an unexpected turn when they visit the peculiar Mr. Reed, who invites them into his dimly lit home. Reed’s cryptic remarks about his house being made of “metal” and the strange absence of his wife set the stage for the psychological chess game that follows. As Reed challenges their faith, forcing them to confront uncomfortable truths and existential questions, the missionaries’ belief system begins to unravel. The heart of Heretic lies in Reed’s philosophical musings and his manipulative tactics, which pull Paxton and Barnes deeper into his twisted world.

Character Development

Hugh Grant delivers a masterclass in subtlety as Mr. Reed, his charm and warmth masking a darker, more calculating side. Chloe East as Sister Paxton captures the vulnerability and internal struggle of a young woman questioning her long-held beliefs, while Sophie Thatcher’s Sister Barnes exudes both strength and hesitation as she navigates the moral labyrinth Reed presents. The film’s strength lies in these performances, as the characters grapple with their faith and doubts, and the inevitable clash between trust and skepticism.

Themes and Direction

The central theme of Heretic is a battle between belief and disbelief. Reed’s manipulation and philosophical arguments force the missionaries to question the foundation of their faith. While the film poses thought-provoking questions about the nature of belief, it doesn’t quite follow through on its ambitious premise. Beck and Woods introduce a fascinating psychological dynamic but allow the narrative to devolve into more predictable horror tropes. The setting is atmospheric, with the house itself almost becoming a character, adding to the sense of isolation and growing tension.

Pacing and Narrative

The film starts strong, with Reed’s cryptic nature and philosophical questioning creating a tense atmosphere. However, as the story progresses, the suspense gradually gives way to conventional horror elements that feel forced and predictable. The psychological tension that is built up in the first act ultimately fizzles out, replaced by a series of cliched horror sequences that detract from the film’s intellectual exploration of faith.

What Worked

Hugh Grant’s performance as the enigmatic Mr. Reed is captivating, bringing depth and intrigue to the film.
The psychological exploration of faith, doubt, and manipulation is thought-provoking, especially in the first half.
The film’s atmospheric direction and eerie setting contribute to a sense of unease.

What Didn’t Work

The narrative loses steam as it transitions from a philosophical debate to predictable horror tropes.
The film’s exploration of faith feels more like a plot device than a deep, meaningful inquiry.
Some of the supporting characters, particularly the mysterious “Mrs. Reed,” remain underdeveloped and fail to add much to the plot.

Final Verdict: 3/5 Stars

Heretic presents an intriguing premise but fails to fully deliver on its promise. The first half is a gripping exploration of faith and manipulation, heightened by strong performances from the lead cast. However, as the film veers into familiar horror territory, it loses the philosophical weight that initially made it so compelling. Despite its shortcomings, Heretic is worth watching for those intrigued by psychological thrillers and the exploration of faith’s complexities.

Should You Watch It?

If you’re a fan of slow-burn psychological thrillers that delve into faith, belief, and manipulation, Heretic might appeal to you. While it doesn’t fully live up to its potential, the performances and atmosphere make it an engaging watch for those willing to overlook its predictable third act.

Heretic Movie Review