A dispute over a $330 million estate has escalated into a broader debate on the functioning of a New York court. Brandon Bishunauth, 23, is contesting the management of his late father’s estate in Queens Surrogate’s Court following the passing of real estate businessman Mohammad Malik in February 2023.
The estate, valued at $330 million based on assessments, has come under scrutiny in a recent investigative report from January 2025. The report highlighted potential political influences within Queens judicial circles, particularly noting the involvement of the law firm Sweeney, Reich & Bolz in the selection of judges in the borough.
Allegations in Bishunauth’s appellate filings accuse Surrogate Judge Peter J. Kelly of deliberate violations of the law, including the use of a “Secret Court Docket” instead of the state’s electronic filing system, NYSCEF. These actions are claimed to have impeded due process rights and hindered the consideration of crucial motions.
Under the terms of Malik’s 2023 will, Bishunauth was bequeathed $25,000, with the majority of the estate designated for his sister, Yasmin Malik. However, Bishunauth argues that procedural irregularities during a December 5, 2023, proceeding have raised doubts about the validity of the will and subsequent probate decree.
The case is now under review by the Appellate Division, Second Department, which will assess the validity of the decree, sealing order, and any alleged procedural breaches. Queens Surrogate’s Court, responsible for handling wills and estate disputes, has faced criticism in the past for its perceived connections to local political entities. This ongoing legal battle has reignited concerns over the court’s operations.
